The Role of Eyewitness Testimony in a Criminal Case

Lewis & Laws, PLLC is backed by more than four decades of combined experience, a quality that you cannot find at all defense law firms.

  • Home
  • Blog
  • The Role of Eyewitness Testimony in a Criminal Case

Get a FREE case review now.

We are available 24/7 to take your call. (206) 209-0608

Jun 08

Lewis & Laws

The Role of Eyewitness Testimony in a Criminal Case

by Lewis & Laws

If you are facing criminal charges, you may wonder how much weight eyewitness testimony will carry in your case. For decades, eyewitness testimony has been considered one of the most compelling forms of evidence in criminal trials. However, recent studies have shown that eyewitness testimony is not always accurate and often unreliable. Many different factors can influence an eyewitness’ memory and the details they remember.

How can eyewitness testimony be flawed? Eyewitness testimony is often inaccurate because of the fallibility of human memory. Our memories are not perfect and are influenced by numerous factors, including stress, fear, and time. In addition, eyewitnesses may be influenced by leading questions, suggestive lineups, and other factors that can affect the accuracy of their testimony. As a result, eyewitness testimony is not always reliable, and criminal defense lawyers can challenge this testimony in court.

Factors That Affect Eyewitness Testimony

Understanding the limitations of eyewitness testimony is critical in a criminal defense case. Judges, juries, and attorneys must work together to ensure a fair trial and prevent wrongful convictions. 

Several factors can affect the reliability of eyewitness testimony, including:

Stress and Trauma: Witnesses who have experienced a traumatic event may have difficulty accurately recalling what happened. They may even have gaps in their memory where important details should be.

Memory: Our memories are not always accurate. They’re heavily influenced by many factors, including our own past, time, the type of event we witnessed, and stress. 

Suggestive Tactics: Police officers and investigators often use suggestive tactics when conducting witness interviews. This can lead to mistaken eyewitness identification and unreliable testimony.

Flawed Identification Procedures: The way police conduct lineups and photo arrays can influence witness identification, leading to mistaken identifications.

Lighting and Construction: The physical environment in which the crime took place may affect the reliability of eyewitness testimony. Factors such as lighting and construction can make it difficult for witnesses to recall what happened with accuracy.

Confidence: Witnesses who are confident in their testimony may be more convincing to jurors. However, confidence does not necessarily indicate the accuracy of the testimony.

The Effect of Eyewitness Testimony on Juries

Eyewitness testimony can have a powerful effect on juries. Jurors often view eyewitness testimony as reliable and persuasive, even though it can be flawed. 

To address the issue of wrongful convictions based on eyewitness testimony, some jurisdictions have implemented reforms such as double-blind lineups, where the officer administering the lineup does not know who the suspect is, and expert witnesses testify about the validity of eyewitness testimony.

Contact Our Seattle Criminal Defense Lawyers Today

If you or someone you love is facing criminal charges, you need an aggressive team of criminal defense lawyers to help you through this difficult time. If there is eyewitness testimony against you, we can build a case to expose the flaws in that testimony and create doubt in the jurors’ minds. 

At Lewis & Laws, we offer aggressive legal assistance after an arrest in Seattle, Bellevue, Everett, and throughout Washington state. Contact us today to explore your legal options.

Get answers

Should I plead guilty?

Once you plead guilty to a charge, you cannot change your plea afterwards, so it always advised that you talk with a criminal defense attorney at our firm before you do this. Pleading guilty means that you are admitting your conduct is punishable by the law and you know...

Why do I need a lawyer?

A criminal charge means that you could face sanctions including jail times, fines, probation, potential loss of your driver's license and other penalties. A skilled criminal defense attorney can guide you through the court process and advocate your position in order...

May 17, 2024

Alternatives to Incarceration for Juveniles in Seattle

If your child has been arrested in Seattle, it's completely understandable that you're concerned about their future. We understand that the thought of your child facing criminal charges is...

May 3, 2024

Avoiding Accidental Violations of Protective Orders

If you have a protective order issued against you in Seattle, you must take it seriously and understand exactly what it means. Protective orders, also known as restraining orders or...